Netflix’s Award-Winning Seven-Part Western Is the Perfect Follow-Up to 1883 — and Some Critics Believe It’s Even Better Than Taylor Sheridan’s Hit

Fans of Taylor Sheridan’s 1883 who have been searching for another powerful Western drama may find exactly what they are looking for in a critically acclaimed Netflix miniseries that deserves far more attention.
Godless, a seven-part Western created by Scott Frank, delivers the same rugged frontier atmosphere, emotional storytelling and unforgettable characters that made the Yellowstone prequel such a compelling watch.
Starring Jeff Daniels, Michelle Dockery, Jack O’Connell and Merritt Wever, the drama transports audiences to the American West during the 1880s, where a small community faces a terrifying threat from a ruthless outlaw.
Although Godless arrived several years before 1883, the two productions share remarkable similarities in their settings, themes and portrayals of women struggling to survive in a dangerous world.
And while Sheridan’s series attracted considerable attention through its connection to Yellowstone, Godless has an impressive awards record of its own.
What Is Netflix’s Godless About?

Released in 2017, Godless is set in 1884 and follows the escalating conflict between a notorious criminal and a former member of his gang.
Jeff Daniels plays Frank Griffin, a feared outlaw whose violent reputation makes him a dangerous enemy.
Jack O’Connell portrays Roy Goode, a young man who has become disillusioned with Griffin’s criminal activities.
After turning against his former associate, Roy finds refuge near La Belle, a remote New Mexico mining town.
There, he encounters Alice Fletcher, played by Michelle Dockery, an independent widow who lives on a ranch with her family.
Alice offers the wounded fugitive shelter, placing her in the path of a conflict that threatens the entire community.
But La Belle is no ordinary frontier settlement.
A devastating mining accident has killed most of the town’s men, leaving its women responsible for maintaining their homes, livelihoods and community.
When Griffin’s gang begins closing in on Roy, the residents must confront a danger that could destroy everything they have struggled to preserve.
The Women of La Belle Give the Western a Different Perspective

One of the most distinctive aspects of Godless is its focus on female characters.
Traditional Westerns frequently centre on gunfighters, lawmen and outlaws, with women occupying supporting roles.
Scott Frank’s series takes a different approach.
Although Roy and Griffin drive much of the central conflict, the women of La Belle provide the story with its emotional foundation.
Michelle Dockery’s Alice Fletcher is a resilient ranch owner who has already endured considerable hardship.
She lives with her mother-in-law, Iyovi, portrayed by Tantoo Cardinal, and her son Truckee, played by Samuel Marty.
Merritt Wever plays Mary Agnes McNue, another widow who becomes one of the town’s most determined figures.
Mary Agnes has rebuilt her life following her husband’s death and develops a relationship with Callie Dunne, portrayed by Tess Frazer.
Together, these characters demonstrate the strength required to maintain a community in an environment where danger is never far away.
Their determination becomes especially important as Griffin’s gang approaches La Belle.
Why Godless Feels Like a Companion to 1883

Created by Taylor Sheridan, 1883 explores the origins of the Dutton family decades before the events of Yellowstone.
The ten-part prequel follows James Dutton, played by Tim McGraw, and his wife Margaret, portrayed by Faith Hill, as they undertake a difficult journey westward with their family.
Sam Elliott stars as Shea Brennan, who helps lead the wagon train across dangerous territory.
Isabel May plays Elsa Dutton, whose perspective gives the story much of its emotional power.
Like Godless, the series depicts the harsh realities of frontier existence, including violence, loss and the struggle to establish a better life.
Both productions also place significant emphasis on women who must demonstrate extraordinary resilience.
In 1883, characters such as Margaret Dutton, Claire Dutton and Noemi face devastating challenges while trying to protect their families.
In Godless, Alice Fletcher and Mary Agnes McNue confront similarly unforgiving circumstances.
Although the stories are unrelated, their shared themes make them natural viewing companions.
Jeff Daniels Delivers an Emmy-Winning Performance
One of Godless‘ greatest strengths is its cast.
Jeff Daniels delivers a commanding performance as Frank Griffin, a character whose unsettling presence drives much of the drama’s tension.
The role marked the actor’s first Western and earned him significant recognition.
Daniels won the Primetime Emmy Award for Outstanding Supporting Actor in a Limited Series or Movie for his performance.
Merritt Wever also received a Primetime Emmy for her portrayal of Mary Agnes McNue.
The series collected three Primetime Emmy Awards in total.
Its success extended beyond the Emmys, with the production also receiving recognition for its casting.
The awards helped establish Godless as one of Netflix’s most accomplished Western dramas.
By comparison, 1883 received three Primetime Emmy nominations but did not secure a win.
Awards are not a definitive measure of quality, but the contrast demonstrates the strong critical recognition achieved by Frank’s miniseries.
The Acclaimed Writer Behind The Queen’s Gambit
Another reason Godless stands out is the creative involvement of Scott Frank.
Before developing Netflix’s hugely successful chess drama The Queen’s Gambit, Frank wrote and directed all seven episodes of Godless.
His extensive film career includes screenwriting credits on Get Shorty, Out of Sight, Minority Report, The Lookout and Logan.
That experience is evident in the miniseries’ tightly connected storylines and carefully developed characters.
Rather than spreading the narrative across multiple seasons, Frank tells a complete Western story within seven episodes.
The result is a focused drama that combines cinematic production values with the extended character development possible in television.
Its deliberate pacing allows viewers to understand the people of La Belle before the conflict surrounding Roy and Griffin reaches its most dangerous stage.
Is Godless Better Than 1883?
Comparisons between the two series inevitably come down to personal preference.
1883 benefits from its connection to the larger Yellowstone universe, offering audiences a deeper understanding of the Dutton family’s history.
Its sweeping journey across the American frontier also provides a different narrative structure from the town-centred story of Godless.
Frank’s miniseries, meanwhile, places greater emphasis on a single community and the people forced to defend it.
Its acclaimed ensemble performances and compact storytelling have made it a particularly strong example of the modern Western.
For viewers who prefer tightly constructed limited series, Godless may have the advantage.
Those who enjoy expansive family sagas may remain more attached to Sheridan’s production.
Nevertheless, both dramas explore survival, sacrifice and the personal consequences of life on the nineteenth-century frontier.
Why Western Fans Should Add Godless to Their Watchlist
With only seven episodes, Godless offers a complete story that can be enjoyed without committing to several seasons.
Its dramatic New Mexico setting, morally complicated characters and formidable female leads distinguish it from more conventional Westerns.
The performances by Daniels, Dockery, O’Connell and Wever provide compelling reasons to watch, while Scott Frank’s writing gives the series a strong narrative foundation.
For audiences who admired the emotional intensity of 1883, the Netflix drama offers a similarly immersive journey into the American West.
It also works as a standalone story, requiring no familiarity with Yellowstone or Sheridan’s other productions.
Nearly a decade after its original release, Godless remains a powerful seven-part Western that deserves a place on the watchlist of anyone who enjoyed 1883. All seven episodes are available to stream on Netflix.